Advantage & Disadvantage, Explained
The simplest good rule in modern d20 games โ and the math behind it.
Advantage and disadvantage are the d20 game's elegant way of saying "this is easier" or "this is harder" without fiddly bonuses. The rule is tiny: roll two d20s instead of one. With advantage, keep the higher die. With disadvantage, keep the lower. That's the whole rule. This guide covers what it does to your odds, how it compares with a flat bonus, and the table conventions that trip people up. If you just want to throw the dice, roll a d20 with advantage on the dice roller.
When do you get it?
The GM grants advantage when circumstances clearly favor you: attacking a surprised enemy, helping an ally, the right tool for the job. Disadvantage comes from anything that hinders you: attacking in the dark, firing at long range, acting while poisoned or frightened. You don't add a number โ you just change how the die is rolled.
A useful test for a GM is to ask whether the situation is clearly better or worse than normal, not whether it is slightly better. A torch in a dim corridor is normal; fighting a creature you cannot see is not. Because advantage is worth a lot in the middle of the d20 range (see below), handing it out for small things quickly makes every check easy. Many tables also let a player earn advantage by describing a clever plan, which rewards attention to the fiction instead of a hunt through the rulebook for small modifiers.
The math: advantage is not a flat +5
A fair d20 averages 10.5. Keeping the higher of two independent d20s averages 13.825; keeping the lower averages 7.175. That is a change of 3.325 in the average die result. The change in your chance of success depends on the number you need, so it cannot be replaced by a fixed modifier.
Let p be the chance that one die meets your target after the modifier. With advantage, both dice must fail for the check to fail, so success is 1 โ (1 โ p)ยฒ. With disadvantage, both must succeed, so success is pยฒ. The table counts all 400 equally likely pairs; it is not a simulation. The last column converts the gain into the flat bonus that would add the same number of percentage points to a single d20 (20 ร p ร (1 โ p)).
| Die needed | One d20 | Advantage | Disadvantage | Advantage worth about |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2+ | 95% | 99.75% | 90.25% | +0.95 |
| 4+ | 85% | 97.75% | 72.25% | +2.55 |
| 6+ | 75% | 93.75% | 56.25% | +3.75 |
| 8+ | 65% | 87.75% | 42.25% | +4.55 |
| 10+ | 55% | 79.75% | 30.25% | +4.95 |
| 11+ | 50% | 75% | 25% | +5 |
| 12+ | 45% | 69.75% | 20.25% | +4.95 |
| 14+ | 35% | 57.75% | 12.25% | +4.55 |
| 16+ | 25% | 43.75% | 6.25% | +3.75 |
| 18+ | 15% | 27.75% | 2.25% | +2.55 |
| 20 | 5% | 9.75% | 0.25% | +0.95 |
At 11+, advantage adds 25 percentage points: the same success-rate increase as +5 on one d20 for this particular target. At 20, it adds only 4.75 percentage points, worth about +1. The pattern is symmetrical: advantage helps most when you are a coin flip and least when you almost always succeed or almost never do. Disadvantage mirrors it, which is why a disadvantaged long shot is close to hopeless โ a check that needs 18+ drops from 15% to 2.25%.
What it does to critical hits
With advantage, the kept die is a natural 20 in 39 of the 400 pairs, so the chance of a critical rises from 5% to 9.75%. A natural 1 needs both dice to show 1, which happens in a single pair: 0.25%. Disadvantage swaps those numbers, so a disadvantaged attack fumbles 9.75% of the time and crits only 0.25% of the time. This matters more than the average suggests for anything built around critical hits, and it is the reason players fight hard for advantage on their big attack of the round.
Check your own odds
Enter the target number (DC) and the bonus added to the die. This is a mathematical threshold check: a natural 1 or 20 has no automatic effect. If your game uses automatic failure or success, apply those rules separately.
DC 15 with +4 needs 11+: one d20 50%; advantage 75%; disadvantage 25%.
Two common conventions
The following are common d20 conventions, not universal rules for every tabletop system. Your game's rulebook and table agreement take precedence.
- It doesn't stack. Three sources of advantage still means roll two dice, keep the higher. You never roll three and keep the best.
- They cancel out. If you have advantage and disadvantage at the same time, they cancel completely โ you roll one normal d20, no matter how many of each you have.
The cancel rule surprises new players: two sources of advantage against one source of disadvantage still leave a single plain d20. It keeps play fast, because nobody has to count sources, but it also means a single hindrance can wipe out careful setup. Some groups house-rule a third die for special abilities. Rolling three d20s and keeping the highest succeeds with 1 โ (1 โ p)ยณ: 87.5% at 11+ and 14.26% at 20, with an average of about 15.5. That is a big step up, so treat it as a rare reward rather than a default.
Common mistakes at the table
- Rolling advantage on damage. It applies to one d20 roll: an attack, a check or a save. Damage pools such as 2d6 are rolled normally.
- Re-rolling instead of rolling together. Both dice are rolled at once. Rolling one, then rolling the second only if the first is low, is a different rule โ and it is easy to forget which one you agreed on.
- Adding the modifier twice. Pick the die first, then add your bonus once to the kept result.
- Treating the dropped die as a second chance. The roll is decided by the kept die alone. If it is a natural 20, the check is a critical; the dropped die does not trigger anything.
Rolling it without the headache
Tracking two physical dice and remembering which to keep is exactly the kind of thing that slows combat down. Set the dice roller to Advantage or Disadvantage and tap d20 โ it rolls both, keeps the right one, and crosses out the die you dropped so the table can see it was fair. One link does it: roll a d20 with advantage, or roll with disadvantage.
- Does advantage apply to damage?
- No. Advantage and disadvantage only affect a single d20 roll โ an attack, a check or a save. Damage pools like 2d6 are rolled normally.
- What if I have advantage from two things?
- Still just two dice, keep the higher. Multiple sources don't add up.
- What happens with both advantage and disadvantage?
- They cancel out entirely and you roll a single normal d20.
- Is advantage better than +5?
- They are equal only when you need exactly 11 or better. For any easier or harder target, a flat +5 adds more success chance than advantage does, but advantage also nearly doubles your chance of a natural 20.
- What is the average d20 roll with advantage?
- 13.825, compared with 10.5 for a single d20. With disadvantage the average falls to 7.175.